Skip to content
WikiBusines
For companies and people whose page already exists

Wikipedia page audit: what happened to it and what can realistically change

We go through the entire history of your page from the day it was created: deletion and protection logs, the talk page, disclosed paid editors, blocked accounts, problem templates, language versions and Wikidata. You get a written answer on what can be changed, how, and what nobody can change. From €490, 5 days.

history since creationlogs and blockschange planno edits during the audit

No page yet? You need a different check: whether your sources will pass the notability rules. Notability Audit →

€490Standard audit, 5 days; credited to the project if ordered within a month
5,000+Wikipedia pages we edit every year
160+language versions we work with
15+years working with Wikipedia, since 2010
01Two different audits

Page audit or Notability Audit: it depends on whether the article exists

The Notability Audit answers the question “can an article be created.” The page audit answers a different one: what has already happened to an existing article, who edited it and how, and what can be done about it under Wikipedia's rules.

no page yet

Notability Audit

  • Whether there are enough independent sources
  • Six notability tests
  • Verdict “yes / not yet” and deletion risk
  • Route: article, Wikidata, or coverage first
Notability Audit: all terms →
page already exists

Page audit

  • Edit history and logs since creation
  • Talk page, paid editors, edit requests
  • Blocks and sockpuppet investigations
  • Problem templates, language versions, Wikidata
  • Plan: what to change, how, and what not to change
Page audit pricing →

The prices are the same: Standard €490, Premium €750, Comprehensive €1,900. The cost of either audit is credited in full toward the project price if you order the project within a month.

02What we check

What a Wikipedia page audit checks: six places where its history lives

Most of what decides an article's fate is not visible on the article itself. It sits in the history, the logs, the talk page and the records about editors. We read all of it from the day of creation and pull it into one report.

autoplay
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Company_N
ArticleTalkView historyLogs
Company N
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
This article contains content that is written like an advertisement. Please help improve it by removing promotional content. (March 2024)
This article relies excessively on references to primary sources. (March 2024)

Company N is a leading global provider of collaboration software, trusted by millions of teams worldwide.[1]

Company N: Revision history
  • 14 Mar 2025Editor F−2,311Removed promotional section, see talk
  • 12 Mar 2025Editor B+2,298Restored content
  • 11 Mar 2025Editor F−2,298Undid revision by Editor B
  • 10 Mar 2025Editor B+2,302Added awards and partners
  • 02 Feb 2025Editor K+46Update infobox
Edit war: 3 reverts in 4 days
Logs: Company N
Deletions, moves and protection: the reason behind every entry
Talk:Company N
Connected contributor (paid) An editor has disclosed that they were paid on behalf of the subject of this article.
Edit request Update CEO and headcount, sources attached. Pending · 41 days
Edit request Remove "leading global provider". Done
Edit request Add 2023 product launch. Declined · press release only
3 requests: one accepted, one declined, one waiting
Block log
  • 2023blocked Editor A with an expiration time of indefinite (Abusing multiple accounts)
  • 2023blocked Editor B with an expiration time of indefinite (Sockpuppet of Editor A)
Wikipedia:Sockpuppet investigations/Editor A2 accounts · ConfirmedBoth accounts edited only Company N
Which editors are blocked and whether they are linked to the subject
Company N in other languages
EnglishCEO: Jane Roe2025
DeutschCEO: John Doe2019
Français—no article
WikidataCEO (P169): John Doeoutdated
Google and AI assistants take facts from here too

Article and problem templates

  • Which banners are in place: advertising, notability, primary sources, conflict of interest
  • When they were added and what must be fixed to have them removed
  • Promotional wording that editors will remove first
In the report: a list of templates and the removal condition for each

Edit history

  • Who edited the article, when, and how much text was removed
  • Reverts and edit wars that attract administrators
  • Edits that look like undisclosed paid editing
In the report: a timeline of key edits since creation

Logs

  • Deletions and their reasons: advertising, notability, copyright
  • Page protection and title protected from creation
  • Moves, merges and title changes
In the report: every log entry and what it means now

Talk page

  • Disclosed paid editors and conflict-of-interest templates
  • Edit requests: which were accepted, which declined, and why
  • Talk page archives and deletion nominations
In the report: what editors have already decided and what they will agree to

Editors and blocks

  • Whether the accounts that edited the article are blocked
  • Sockpuppet investigations linked to the topic
  • Whether a former contractor's history can affect you
In the report: the risk from past accounts and what to do about it

Language versions and Wikidata

  • Factual discrepancies between language versions
  • State of the Wikidata entry: outdated and empty fields
  • Where Google and AI assistants get facts about you
In the report: a table of discrepancies by language
03Red flags

What the audit finds most often: eight flags by risk level

Every finding in the report has a risk level and a plain-language explanation: what it means for you and whether anything can be done about it.

  • critical
    Title protected from creationReason in the log: “repeatedly created; target of undisclosed paid editing.” The article can be created again only through an administrator.
  • critical
    Blocked accounts linked to the topicAn investigation confirmed sockpuppet accounts. Any new anonymous edit in the company's favor will be seen as a continuation.
  • high
    {{Advert}} templateReaders see the “written like an advertisement” banner. It is removed after the text is rewritten, and not by an editor connected to the company.
  • high
    Conflict of interest or hidden payment tagEditors believe the text was written in the company's interest. Every following edit is checked more closely.
  • high
    {{Notability}} templateNotability is in doubt. Without new independent sources this is a step toward a deletion nomination.
  • medium
    Too many primary sourcesLinks to the company's site and press releases. Editors remove facts that rely on them.
  • medium
    Disproportionate sectionOne episode takes up more space than the whole history of the company. The due weight rule gives grounds for an edit request.
  • medium
    Language versions and Wikidata disagreeOne language has the new CEO, another the old one. Google and AI assistants show whatever they find first.
04Cases

Three pages clients come to us with: what the audit showed

Names changed. The situations are typical: we see them every month at companies that come to us after another agency, or after trying to fix the article on their own.

autoplay
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Log/Company_N
Logs: Company N
  • 2019created page Company N
  • 2020deleted page Company N (G11: Unambiguous advertising or promotion)
  • 2021created page Company N
  • 2021deleted page Company N (Articles for deletion/Company N)
  • 2022protected Company N [Create=Require administrator access] (indefinite) (Repeatedly recreated; target of undisclosed paid editing)
TITLE PROTECTED
Company N · team software · English Wikipedia
What the audit found

Two attempts to create the article from undisclosed accounts. The first time it was deleted as advertising, the second after a discussion: there were not enough independent sources. The title was protected from creation indefinitely, with a note about undisclosed paid editing.

What can be changed

Collect independent sources, write a draft from a disclosed account and ask the administrator who protected the title to review it. While sources are few, start with Wikidata.

What we did not promise

That an administrator will agree, or a specific date. Only Wikipedia administrators decide on protection.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Sockpuppet_investigations
Sockpuppet investigations/Editor A
  • Mar 2023Case opened: Editor A, Editor B (both edit only Company K)
  • Mar 2023CheckUser: Confirmed (Editor A = Editor B)
  • Mar 2023blocked Editor A indefinite (Abusing multiple accounts)
  • Mar 2023blocked Editor B indefinite (Sockpuppet of Editor A)
Talk:Company K This article may have been edited in exchange for undisclosed payments. Please review.
Company K · B2B service · English Wikipedia
What the audit found

Two accounts that edited only the company's article were blocked indefinitely after an investigation. Most likely a former contractor. The talk page carries a warning about undisclosed payment.

What can be changed

Disclose openly in WikiBusines' name, acknowledge the history on the talk page and propose edits only as requests with independent sources. This is how an article is gradually brought back to neutral text.

What we do not do

New accounts, block evasion, requests to unblock other people's accounts. That is the fastest route to the article's deletion.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Company_L
Company L

Company L is a software company known for a series of security incidents between 2021 and 2023.

Share of article text
History 14%Products 9%Security incidents 52%Other 25%
Proposed lead (edit request) Company L is a software company founded in 2008 that develops software for small businesses. In 2022 and 2023 it disclosed security incidents.
Company L · online service · English Wikipedia
What the audit found

The first sentence defines the company through incidents, and the incidents section takes up half the article. The products section is short because it relied on press releases, and editors cut it.

What can be changed

Propose a balanced first sentence, and history and products sections based on independent sources. The due weight rule gives grounds for this.

What nobody can change

Incidents described in independent sources stay in the article. You can demand accuracy and proportion, but not removal.

05What can change

What can be changed in an existing article: an honest boundary before work begins

The report sorts everything you want into three baskets. You pay for work only from the first two: we do not take on the third.

Can be donethrough edit requests
  • Fix outdated facts: CEO, headcount, address
  • Add events from independent sources
  • Balance the sections under the due weight rule
  • Remove promotional wording so the banner can be taken down
  • Synchronize language versions and Wikidata
Possible, but no guaranteed timelineeditors decide
  • Reopen a protected title through an administrator
  • Bring back a deleted article through a new draft
  • Remove the notability template after new sources
  • Respond to a deletion nomination
Cannot be donenobody can change it
  • Delete criticism from independent sources
  • Hide the edit history or the logs
  • Buy protection or the lifting of a block
  • Edit the article with an undisclosed conflict of interest
06How we act after the audit

Changes to an existing article: openly, through the talk page

The company the article is about has a conflict of interest, and so do we as its contractor. That is why we do not edit such an article directly: we disclose the payment in WikiBusines' name and propose edits on the talk page. An independent editor decides.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:WikiBusines_editor
User:WikiBusines editor
Paid contribution disclosure This user is paid by WikiBusines on behalf of Company N. They will not edit the article directly and will propose changes on the talk page.
Talk:Company N · Edit request
{{Edit COI}} Please replace the second paragraph of the lead.
Company N is a leading global provider trusted by millions.Company N develops collaboration software; in 2024 it reported 1,200 employees.
Sources: 2 independent articles, 1 annual report
Talk:Company N · Edit request
Status Answered by an independent editor
Done Lead updated. The employee figure is cited to the annual report.
Partly done "Trusted by millions" removed, award left out: no independent source.
WikiMonitoring · Company N
New edit Editor X · −312 bytes · section "Products"
Talk page New message in thread "Edit request"
Wikidata CEO (P169) updated in 4 language versions

We disclose the payment

On the user page and on the article's talk page we state that we work for pay in WikiBusines' name, and for whom. The Wikimedia Terms of Use require this.

We propose an edit with sources

Every change is written as a request: what to replace, with what, and with which independent sources. The text is neutral, otherwise it will be declined.

We wait for the editor's decision

A volunteer with no connection to the topic reviews the request. It can take from a few days to a few weeks, so in the plan we set realistic timelines.

We monitor the article

After the changes we watch the edits, the talk page and the Wikidata entry, so that we can respond in time if someone reverts what was accepted.

07Pricing

Wikipedia page audit pricing: the same three tiers

The prices are the same as for the Notability Audit. The tiers differ in the number of language versions and sources and in the depth of the plan.

Standard5 days
€490

One language version, the full picture.

  • 1 language version of the article
  • Edit history and all logs since creation
  • The talk page and its archives
  • Editor blocks and sockpuppet investigations
  • Problem templates and the conditions for removing them
  • Review of up to 15 sources that can be added
  • Risk level for every finding
  • Written plan: what to change, how, and what not to change
Choose Standard
Premium5–7 daysmost popular
€750

Two languages, Wikidata and a plan you can act on.

  • Everything in Standard
  • 2 language versions and the Wikidata entry
  • 25–40 sources, including non-English ones
  • How your competitors' articles are written
  • 30-minute call on the results
Choose Premium
Comprehensive1–2 weeks
€1,900

Many languages and high stakes.

  • Everything in Premium
  • All language versions of the article
  • Exhaustive source search, including offline
  • How Google and AI assistants see the article
  • Risk memo for lawyers and PR
  • 60-minute strategy session and written answers
Choose Comprehensive
100%of the audit cost is credited toward the project price (editing, restoration, WikiMonitoring or annual support) if you order it within a month after the report.
08Steps and brief

From brief to report: four steps, 5 days in Standard

The audit starts with a short brief from you. The most important part of it is an honest history: who on your side or among your contractors has already edited the article.

1
day 0

Brief and payment

You send the brief, we confirm the language versions and the tier.

2
days 1–3

History review

We read the history, logs, talk page, block records, language versions and Wikidata.

3
days 3–5

Sources and plan

We check which sources can be added and write a change plan with realistic timelines.

4
day 5

Report

A written report, plus a call in Premium and Comprehensive. After that, you decide what to do.

Audit brief5 items, 15 minutes
  1. Links to the article and all its language versions
  2. What you are unhappy with — point by point, in your own words
  3. Who has already edited the article on your side or among your contractors, and from which accounts
  4. Sources you have: articles, reports, interviews
  5. Goal and deadline: what you want to achieve and by when

During the audit we edit nothing on Wikipedia and mention your order nowhere.

09FAQ

Questions about the Wikipedia page audit: in brief

How is a page audit different from a Notability Audit?

The Notability Audit is for an article that does not exist yet: it checks whether there are enough sources to create it. The page audit is for an article that already exists: what has happened to it, who has edited it, which templates and restrictions are on it, and what can be done about them. The prices are the same.

Can I just remove the “advertisement” template from the article?

No. The template is removed when the problem has been fixed, and an independent editor does it. If an account connected to the company removes it, the template will be put back and the article will get closer scrutiny. We propose the fix on the talk page and ask for the template to be reviewed.

The article's title is protected from creation. Can it be reopened?

Only a Wikipedia administrator can reopen it. A chance appears when there is a draft based on independent sources that removes the reason for deletion, and a request from a disclosed editor. We promise neither timing nor outcome: the administrator decides.

A previous agency edited the article opaquely, and the accounts are blocked. What now?

Tell us everything you know: which accounts edited and when. We do not evade blocks and do not create new accounts. We work openly, in WikiBusines' name, through edit requests. It is slower, but this is how the article can be kept.

Can criticism or incidents be removed from the article?

If they are described in independent sources, no. What you can get is accuracy, up-to-date sources and proportion: one episode should not take up half the article, and the company's history and products should be described in the same detail.

Will you edit the article directly?

No. We disclose the payment in WikiBusines' name and propose changes on the article's talk page. An independent editor decides. The conflict-of-interest rules require this, and it is also why the changes are not reverted afterwards.

How long do changes take after the audit?

It depends on what we are changing. An edit request is reviewed in anywhere from a few days to a few weeks, and reopening a protected title takes longer. The realistic timeline for each item is in the plan in the report.

What do you need from us to start?

A short brief: a link to the article and its language versions, what exactly you are unhappy with, who on your side has already edited the article, which sources you have, and your goal and deadline. The brief form is at the bottom of the page.

Is the audit cost credited if I order the project within a month?

Yes, in full. If within a month after the report you order a project from us (editing, restoration, WikiMonitoring or annual support), the cost of the audit is deducted from its price.

Do you check other language versions and Wikidata?

Standard covers one language version, Premium two and the Wikidata entry, Comprehensive all language versions of the article. Discrepancies between languages go into the report as a separate table.

What if the audit shows that nothing can be changed?

We will say so, with the reasons. We do not take on work that has no chance under Wikipedia's rules. Instead we will suggest what can be done outside the article: a Wikidata entry, new independent publications, your own knowledge hub for AI.

Will anyone on Wikipedia find out that we ordered an audit?

No. The audit works only with public pages and logs. We edit nothing and mention your order nowhere. Disclosure appears only when you order changes and we begin working on the talk page.

Page already exists? Let's start with its history

Send the brief, and within one business day we will tell you which tier you need and whether we see anything critical right away.

  • 1Audit from €490, 5 days
  • 2Nothing is edited during the audit
  • 3Cost credited to the project within a month

By submitting the form, you agree to the privacy policy.